For what it's worth, most peoples experience so far has been quite positive.
And that is good although I can't imagine that they have actually given it a thorough once over.
It should be noted that I am not unhappy with Lucid Puppy. The basic set of apps that have been staples of official Puppy releases seem to work quite well. However as I have pointed out there are some critical issues with the package manager and clearly attention to detail is not what it once was.
For what it is worth the first setup was on my netbook so I decided to install on my desktop. It won't even go there. It can't find my SATA hard drive and drops out of initial ram drive console. Hmm....
Well if this is the direction Puppy is headed in, good luck. I hope that it works out for you.