HDD failure imminent. What to do?
When the computer reboots to live CD, it does not read the /slackosave.3fs file, but instead reads only puppy_slacko_5.7.0.sfs main file. When the computer reboots to frugal install, it reads the /slackosave file, and then the puppy_slacko.sfs file.
Last edited by nubc on Sun 10 Sep 2017, 20:15, edited 2 times in total.
That doesn't work. The frugal boots from CD.bigpup wrote: Do not have the live CD in the CD player when you boot.
EDIT: Maybe if I remove the CD just before "Searching for Puppy files..."
Nah, that's too tricky. Every other reboot, it does not load the slackosave file. In the case where it boots to live CD, it may be getting the Puppy files off the CD instead of the USB. When it boots frugal, it gets the slackosave file and the sfs files off the USB, probably.
So, the problem is the save file is only getting seen sometimes.nubc wrote:When the computer reboots to live CD, it does not read the /slackosave.3fs file, but instead reads only puppy_slacko_5.7.0.sfs file. When the computer reboots to frugal install, it reads the /slackosave file, and then the puppy_slacko.sfs file.
I am having confusion by how you are stating what you are booting.
I am understanding that as you are booting using Slacko installed on a CD.When the computer reboots to live CD
It sometimes finds the save file and sometimes does not.
The things they do not tell you, are usually the clue to solving the problem.
When I was a kid I wanted to be older.... This is not what I expected
YaPI(any iso installer)
When I was a kid I wanted to be older.... This is not what I expected
YaPI(any iso installer)
When you burn the Slacko iso image to a CD, you have installed Slacko on the CD.Slacko installed on CD, probably not. Slacko .iso burned to CD, and yes
Usually called a live Slacko CD.
Exactly where is the savefile located?
Be very specific with location details!!!!!
Is this the only save file or are there other slackosaves?
If there are other slackosaves.
Exact names and locations.
Be specific with info!!!!
Where the savefile is located can affect how the live Slacko CD finds a savefile to use.
The things they do not tell you, are usually the clue to solving the problem.
When I was a kid I wanted to be older.... This is not what I expected
YaPI(any iso installer)
When I was a kid I wanted to be older.... This is not what I expected
YaPI(any iso installer)
Savefile is on thumb drive, which system has named sda1 with both hard drives disconnected. After I installed/created savefile on thumb drive, however, it became locked and unmountable. This motivated me work on the original system with two hard drives, so to that end, I completely removed thumb drive from the computer. The system booted up first try and I managed to offload about 15 GB from the full drive, sda2, before the system crashed. The system crashed, and then I found a very useful boot option, namely
which runs a filesystem check on the save file before booting.
After a couple more reboots I managed to offload a total of 50 GB of data
The last directory that I offloaded contained about 550 files, and the transfer of 5 of those files produced an error, that file could not be extended. What does this mean?
Code: Select all
puppy pfix=fsckAfter a couple more reboots I managed to offload a total of 50 GB of data
The last directory that I offloaded contained about 550 files, and the transfer of 5 of those files produced an error, that file could not be extended. What does this mean?
Here we are, 4 PM on Monday, and the new drive has arrived. My new strategy. Full install of Slacko 5.7.0 on sda1, sized 30 GB. I seem to recall that Legacy Grub did not work on Slacko 5.7, requiring a special .pet from rscn21. Can someone confirm this? I guess I'll set up the new drive, and then install the old 2 TB drive beside it, then try to transfer data. I must say, there are serious issues with the filesystem on this old drive, specifically sda2. You say GParted can fix problems non-destructively? Please advise.
Does GParted 0.16.0 (Slacko 5.7.0) have a size limitation? Can't set up the sda2 partition, which is over 3 TB in size. Is this a kernel issue, because GParted on Slacko 6.3 failed to create the partition as well. I also ran the latest live CD of GParted, and it failed.
Ach, I should have selected the gpt partition table.
Ach, I should have selected the gpt partition table.
What's wrong with my grub menu.lst?
I selected the Full install option provided by grub, but it labels the install as Frugal regardless.
Does anyone have the .pet legacy grub upgrade by rcrsn51?
I wish I could take a look at the boot folder on the old hard drive but it is not working at all right now.
I got a feeling that the MBR is munged, and I will have to perform a deep wipe of sda1 just to recover MBR.
What are the alternative designations for root (hd0,0)?
pmedia=atahd is obviously wrong, because the drive is SATA
Code: Select all
timeout 10
default 0
#
title Puppy Linux Frugal on sda1
root (hd0,0)
kernel /vmlinuz pmedia=atahd pdev1=sda1 pfix=fsck
initrd /initrd.gz
#
title Windows on (hd0,0)
root (hd0,0)
chainloader +1
#
title Ubuntu on (hd0,0)
root (hd0,0)
kernel /boot/grub/core.imgDoes anyone have the .pet legacy grub upgrade by rcrsn51?
I wish I could take a look at the boot folder on the old hard drive but it is not working at all right now.
I got a feeling that the MBR is munged, and I will have to perform a deep wipe of sda1 just to recover MBR.
What are the alternative designations for root (hd0,0)?
pmedia=atahd is obviously wrong, because the drive is SATA
What bootloader for GPT disk?
I've installed Lagacy GRUB which operates in two stages. I installed Legacy GRUB 2013 Configuration from Slacko 6.3.
The difference between booting MBR and GPT with GRUB
https://www.anchor.com.au/blog/2012/10/ ... with-grub/
Booting from GPT, by Rod Smith
http://www.rodsbooks.com/gdisk/booting.html
Booting GPT disk on BIOS systems
http://www.lightofdawn.org/wiki/wiki.cgi/BIOSBootGPT
Hybrid MBRs, by Rod Smith
[http://www.rodsbooks.com/gdisk/hybrid.html
GRUB2: Heal your bootloader
https://www.linuxvoice.com/grub-2-heal-your-bootloader/
I've installed Lagacy GRUB which operates in two stages. I installed Legacy GRUB 2013 Configuration from Slacko 6.3.
The difference between booting MBR and GPT with GRUB
https://www.anchor.com.au/blog/2012/10/ ... with-grub/
Booting from GPT, by Rod Smith
http://www.rodsbooks.com/gdisk/booting.html
Booting GPT disk on BIOS systems
http://www.lightofdawn.org/wiki/wiki.cgi/BIOSBootGPT
Hybrid MBRs, by Rod Smith
[http://www.rodsbooks.com/gdisk/hybrid.html
GRUB2: Heal your bootloader
https://www.linuxvoice.com/grub-2-heal-your-bootloader/
Last edited by nubc on Tue 12 Sep 2017, 16:38, edited 1 time in total.
No, it's a bootloader issue. As you found in your research above, Grub2 is the proper solution for GPT booting, and most Linux distros have moved on to Grub2.nubc wrote:Question: Does a frugal install avoid this booting GPT disk issue?
Puppy doesn't have an official Grub2 solution. There are rumors of workarounds for older Grub but I haven't tested any. Maybe someone else has.
What is the strategy for booting a GPT disk? If I can't boot the GPT disk, maybe I need to attach a device to the computer that will boot, like a USB flash drive.
I am looking at the new drive from a frugal linstall that boots from CD and stores a savefile on a USB drive. Are you saying that if I instead place the savefile on sda1, the 30-GB partition on the new 4TB hdd, that it won't boot up?
Could I not transfer the savefile that is currently running on the flashdrive to the new partition sda1, and have a frugal install that boots from CD?
Maybe I could install a distro with GRUB2, then surgically remove the OS and substitute Puppy Slacko. Or if could find a distro that installs GRUB2 as an independent operation. Any suggestions for a distro? Ubuntu?
You'd think that Hiren's bootCD or some specialty utility distro (eg SystemRescueCD) would be able to install GRUB2.
I am looking at the new drive from a frugal linstall that boots from CD and stores a savefile on a USB drive. Are you saying that if I instead place the savefile on sda1, the 30-GB partition on the new 4TB hdd, that it won't boot up?
Could I not transfer the savefile that is currently running on the flashdrive to the new partition sda1, and have a frugal install that boots from CD?
Maybe I could install a distro with GRUB2, then surgically remove the OS and substitute Puppy Slacko. Or if could find a distro that installs GRUB2 as an independent operation. Any suggestions for a distro? Ubuntu?
You'd think that Hiren's bootCD or some specialty utility distro (eg SystemRescueCD) would be able to install GRUB2.
The legacy GRUB installer is here.
It will work with a GPT partition table.
How have you formatted the drive? I can't remember if legacy GRUB will boot from an ext4 partition. Also, I don't know how it will react to very large partitions.
It will work with a GPT partition table.
How have you formatted the drive? I can't remember if legacy GRUB will boot from an ext4 partition. Also, I don't know how it will react to very large partitions.
Grub2 is kinda tied to the OS, you can look around for standalone Grub2 options, but defeats the purpose somewhat.nubc wrote:Maybe I could install a distro with GRUB2, then surgically remove the OS and substitute Puppy Slacko. Or if could find a distro that installs GRUB2 as an independent operation. Any suggestions for a distro? Ubuntu?
You'd think that Hiren's bootCD or some specialty utility distro (eg SystemRescueCD) would be able to install GRUB2.
You can install a basic netinstall Debian 9 in less than 1GB that has Base OS minus Xwin and full Grub2. Ubuntu base install is bigger but also works.
Unlike you, I don't have any >2TB drives so I never needed to switch off Grub4DOS, which is simple and easy. The Grub2 bloatware I leave on the other distros PBR.(such as Arch, Debian, Fedora)
That's good news, rcrsn51. I have installed Legacy Grub 2013 from Slacko 6.3. It doesn't work, possibly because of the (hd0,0) lettering options. Do you have any suggestions? Here's my menu.lst from grub.
I didn't like the Slacko 5.7 grub, so I used a DOS floppy to rewrite the MBR.
Then I installed Legacy Grub 2013 from Slacko 6.3, Still no luck.
I notice that Slacko 5.7 Legacy GRUB 2013 has an extra line
Is this significant?
I just tried to boot from the hard drive, and got this message
Code: Select all
timeout 4
default 0
#
title Puppy Linux Full on sda1
root (hd0,0)
kernel /boot/vmlinuz root=/dev/sda1 ro vga=normalCode: Select all
C:/ fdisk /mbrThen I installed Legacy Grub 2013 from Slacko 6.3, Still no luck.
I notice that Slacko 5.7 Legacy GRUB 2013 has an extra line
Code: Select all
initrd /initrd.gz I just tried to boot from the hard drive, and got this message
Code: Select all
No boot device availableJust out of curiosity, I did a test on VBox and could not get that Grub Legacy to work on a GPT disk. No valid boot device error. Grub2 worked fine though.
Is this Grub Legacy package the same as what is in Slacko 6.3.2? I tried that too and it also did not work. Maybe it would on real hardware, but I have no spare drives/systems to test at the moment.
EDIT: Never mind, operator error. Forgot that my Vbox test setup install was using 64-bit Ext4. 32-bit Ext4 on GPT worked OK with Grub Legacy.
Last edited by jd7654 on Wed 13 Sep 2017, 08:02, edited 1 time in total.